Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:
Yes you can contribute we are also free to vote NO on them and based upon the poll I would expect you to see a LOT of No votes, and I certainly hope that you do.

You could vote No. But this would violate the voting rules:

Quote:
If a user is following the Contribution Rules and his/her data is accurate, and the contribution replaces data which is inaccurate or violates these Contribution Rules, a "No" vote is considered an abuse of the voting privilege and should be avoided when possible.

How is the lack of production studios inaccurate or in violation of the Rules?

Apparently Rho believes that if it is not covered by the Rules then he is free to interject whatever he wishes and it should be automatically approved. Wrong

Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting CalebAndCo:

Quote:
Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:
Yes you can contribute we are also free to vote NO on them and based upon the poll I would expect you to see a LOT of No votes, and I certainly hope that you do.

You could vote No. But this would violate the voting rules:

Quote:
If a user is following the Contribution Rules and his/her data is accurate, and the contribution replaces data which is inaccurate or violates these Contribution Rules, a "No" vote is considered an abuse of the voting privilege and should be avoided when possible.

How is the lack of production studios inaccurate or in violation of the Rules?

So you think you are allowed to vote No when someone wants to add allowed and accurate data to an empty field?

I was merely pointing out the second clause of the rule you quoted to insist that "No" votes would be voting abuse.  Both conditions must be true for the final clause to kick in.

Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting CalebAndCo:

Quote:
Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:
Yes you can contribute we are also free to vote NO on them and based upon the poll I would expect you to see a LOT of No votes, and I certainly hope that you do.

You could vote No. But this would violate the voting rules:

Quote:
If a user is following the Contribution Rules and his/her data is accurate, and the contribution replaces data which is inaccurate or violates these Contribution Rules, a "No" vote is considered an abuse of the voting privilege and should be avoided when possible.

How is the lack of production studios inaccurate or in violation of the Rules?

So you think you are allowed to vote No when someone wants to add allowed and accurate data to an empty field?

Of course you are free to vote as you like. But as I have said, in my experience the screeners ignore such votes.

I thinjk that if you are adding data that is not spelled out in the Rules, in short if you feel you are FREEE to add whatever you want, I am also free to vote my own conscience and my own logic. If the rules do not apply to putting in such data, then rules likewise do not giovern the voting and i am willing to bet based on the poll and the fuss making here any future attempts on your part will go down in flames and i certainly hope so.

As I said, Rho should I see you adding Production Studio to a Boxset, I will not hesitate to vote No.

Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:

I thinjk that if you are adding data that is not spelled out in the Rules, in short if you feel you are FREEE to add whatever you want, I am also free to vote my own conscience and my own logic. If the rules do not apply to putting in such data, then rules likewise do not giovern the voting and i am willing to bet based on the poll and the fuss making here any future attempts on your part will go down in flames and i certainly hope so.

As I said, Rho should I see you adding Production Studio to a Boxset, I will not hesitate to vote No.

The rules clearly state what data goes into the studio field. That part of the rules is valid for box set profiles as well.

Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:
The poll results, Rho leave very little doubt that you are on the wrong side of this issue.

Since when do polls override the rules?

Quoting RHo:

Quote:
Quoting Prof. Kingsfield:

Quote:
The poll results, Rho leave very little doubt that you are on the wrong side of this issue.

Since when do polls override the rules?

You are outside the Rules on this one, creating your own interpretation. Once again simply to stir the pot. The best that can be said is that astudios are not allowed or disallowed within the Boxset rules. So you are free to try  and others are also free to say No you won't either. Enough is enough, I know what you think, you know what I think. You are not going to change my mind nor i yours (not that I care). Simpl;y put end of discussion, it's going no where, youi do know that if you try and I see it, you will see a guaranteed NO vote and i suspect that I will not be alone. There is nothing further for either of us to say.

I agree with many of the points Rho has brought up on this issue.

Although voters might not want this data entered, adding Studios to the Box Set parent is allowed per the rules.

The rules specifically list the data that is not to be entered and Studios is not one of them. There is no interpretation needed - I can read what we are not to enter.

As such, those voting "no" are violating the guidelines invelos has set up.