Apparently, everyone disagreed that my scans were better. That's your right (though some of you might have been a bit more polite about it). That said, that contribution also corrected a number of inaccuracies to the cast name listing (including no role listed at all for Mario Van Peebles. What about that part? Does it just get dismissed as well?

I certainly did. Should I withdraw and resubmit?

I know it's just semantics and doesn't matter all that much, but just so you guys know, you don't have to "withdraw" a submission to resubmit it.  You can submit it again and the new submission will overwrite the existing one and reset the votes.

Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
For future reference, I believe Ken and Gerri are able to decline or accept profile and image changes separately. So it is possible for the cast changes to go through but not the cover scans. The voters just have to make clear in their vote comments which part they're voting "no" on.

Yes, but in this case there were not changes submitted other than the new scans. Firefly may have tried to make other changes, but they are not part of the submission that I saw.

pdf

Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
For future reference, I believe Ken and Gerri are able to decline or accept profile and image changes separately. So it is possible for the cast changes to go through but not the cover scans.

I can vouch for this.  It happens all the time, since often the decision about cover scans is much more subjective than for data.

Quoting Firefly:

Quote:
(though some of you might have been a bit more polite about it).

Apologies from me, my comment on no vote was made in jest (with a wink emoticon) but i see it could have been taken as impolite

cheers
Rich